DOI: 10.32098/mltj.03.2020.15

Long-Term Clinical and Radiographic Results of ACL Reconstruction: Retrospective Comparison Between Three Techniques (Hamstrings Autograft, Hamstrings Autograft with xEtra-Articular Reconstruction, Bone Patellar Tendon Autograft)

Authors

  • P. Rota Fatebenefratelli S. Pietro Hospital, Rome, Italy
  • E. Monaco La Sapienza University of Rome, Sant’Andrea Hospital, Traumatology Sports Center Kilk Kilgour, Rome, Italy
  • A. Carrozzo La Sapienza University of Rome, Sant’Andrea Hospital, Traumatology Sports Center Kilk Kilgour, Rome, Italy
  • G. Bruni La Sapienza University of Rome, Sant’Andrea Hospital, Traumatology Sports Center Kilk Kilgour, Rome, Italy
  • A. Rota Sandro Pertini Hospital, Rome, Italy
  • A. Ferretti La Sapienza University of Rome, Sant’Andrea Hospital, Traumatology Sports Center Kilk Kilgour, Rome, Italy

edoardomonaco76@gmail.com

Keywords

Anterior cruciate ligament, extra articular reconstruction, hamstring tendon, knee joint, osteoarthritis, pivot-shift

Abstract

Background. There is no consensus in the current literature on which surgical options render the best long-term results after ACL reconstruction in terms of clinical outcomes and development of radiographic osteoarthritis (AO). The aim of this study is to investigate clinical and radiological results at long-term follow up after ACL reconstruction using hamstring tendons autograft (Group HT), hamstrings autograft with extra-articular reconstruction (Group HT-ER), and bone patellar tendon bone autograft (Group BPTB).

Methods. All patients were evaluated at final follow-up using Lysholm, International Knee Documentation Committee (IKDC), and Tegner scores. An arthrometric KT-1000 evaluation was also done. Comparative weight bearing radiographs were taken, including a skyline view for patellofemoral joint and analyzed according to Fairbank, Kellgren, and IKDC classification. Sixty patients were selected for this retrospective study, 20 for each group. The minimum final follow-up was 10 years for each group. All patients were male and involved in sport activities (Tegner pre-injury >7).

Results. Subjective scores improved significantly in all groups, with no significative differences between groups (P<0,05). The number of patients classified as C or D at the IKDC objective activity score was higher in Group HT (2/20, 10%), than in Group BTB (1/20, 5%) and Group HT-E (0/20, 0%). In term of failure-rate, there were no difference between the three groups (P<0,05). Radiologic evaluation shoved more arthritic changes in Group-BT in the patello-femoral joint (PMJ).

Conclusions. All the three techniques showed satisfactory results at long term follow up with no differences in term of subjective scores. Finally, there was a statistically significant higher incidence of arthritic changes in PFJ as evaluated with x-ray in the BPTP group respect to HT and HT + ER groups (p<0.05).

View the entire article

Downloads

This article was originally published by Edra S.p.A. and is made available here as part of the Muscles, Ligaments and Tendons Journal archive. Its inclusion in the current Journal archive does not alter the copyright, licensing, or reuse terms applicable at the time of its original publication.

Published

2020-09-30

How to Cite

1.
Rota P, Monaco E, Carrozzo A, Bruni G, Rota A, Ferretti A. Long-Term Clinical and Radiographic Results of ACL Reconstruction: Retrospective Comparison Between Three Techniques (Hamstrings Autograft, Hamstrings Autograft with xEtra-Articular Reconstruction, Bone Patellar Tendon Autograft). MLTJ [Internet]. 2020 Sep. 30 [cited 2026 Nov. 20];10(3). Available from: https://mltj.online/index.php/mltj/article/view/7214

Most read articles by the same author(s)